Call for Free Consultation: 

Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700

Call For Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700

OVER 75 YEARS OF LEGAL EXCELLENCE IN PERSONAL INJURY LAW

What to Do After a Car Accident That's Not Your Fault
January 22, 2025

What to Do After a Car Accident That's Not Your Fault

Call the police and get a report, photograph everything before the vehicles move, get the other driver's insurance and plate information, and see a doctor the same day even if you feel fine. Then know this: in New York, a car accident not your fault still means your own no-fault insurer pays your medical bills, and you still have to prove the other driver caused it.

Kelner & Kelner has represented seriously injured New Yorkers for decades, and our New York car accident attorneys handle collision cases across the five boroughs and the surrounding counties. Robert S. Kelner and the trial lawyers who work with him see the same avoidable mistakes in the first week of nearly every one of these claims. This article expands on our New York car accident practice.

You've Suffered Enough

We'll go after the compensation you deserve. Don't pay a penny unless we win your case. Contact Kelner & Kelner today at (212) 425-0700 or through our website.

What Should You Do at the Scene of a Car Accident That Is Not Your Fault?

Being right about fault is not the same as being able to prove it. The scene is the only place the proof exists, and it disappears the moment the cars are moved and the witnesses drive off.

  • Call 911 and insist on a police report: even in a low damage collision. A report fixes the date, the location, the vehicles, and the officer's observations, and its absence invites a completely different account later.
  • Photograph before anything moves: the final resting positions of both vehicles, the damage to each, the license plates, skid marks, debris, traffic controls, and the road surface.
  • Photograph the wider scene: the intersection, the sight lines, the signals, and any nearby business or residential cameras that may have captured it.
  • Get witness names and phone numbers yourself: officers do not always record them, and a neutral witness frequently decides a disputed liability case.
  • Exchange the full information: name, license, insurance carrier and policy number, plate, registration, and whether the driver owns the vehicle. If the vehicle is commercial, photograph the company name and the numbers on the door.
  • Say nothing about fault: not to the other driver, not to a bystander, and not to the officer beyond the facts. Do not apologize. An "I'm sorry" spoken out of decency is used as an admission.
  • Do not say you are fine: say you are not sure yet. Adrenaline masks injury for hours.
  • Accept medical evaluation if offered: and if you decline the ambulance, go to urgent care or an emergency department the same day.

What to Do After a Car Accident Not Your Fault: The First Week

The week after the crash determines whether the claim is straightforward or a fight. Three things have to happen: paperwork gets filed on time, treatment gets documented, and you avoid saying anything that helps the other side.

  • Report the accident to your own insurer promptly: even though you did not cause it. Failing to report can jeopardize your own coverage.
  • File the no-fault application within thirty days: this goes to the appropriate no-fault insurer, usually your own, and it is what pays your medical treatment.
  • Make sure providers submit bills within forty-five days: late submission is a routine basis for denial.
  • File the DMV accident report within ten days: required where anyone was injured or property damage exceeds one thousand dollars.
  • Get the police report: and read it. Errors in the narrative, the diagram, or the vehicle assignments happen and can be addressed.
  • Keep every appointment: gaps in treatment are the most effective argument the other side has.
  • Start a simple file: bills, mileage, out-of-pocket costs, missed work, and a short daily note about pain and limitations.
  • Do not post about it: photographs and status updates are pulled and used.

Whose Insurance Pays When the Accident Was Not Your Fault?

Both, for different things. New York's no-fault system means your own insurer pays your medical bills and a portion of lost earnings regardless of who caused the crash. The other driver's liability insurance is what pays for pain and suffering, and only if you can prove fault and meet the statutory injury threshold.

No-fault covers basic economic loss up to fifty thousand dollars per person for treatment and related expenses, plus eighty percent of lost earnings subject to a monthly cap. It pays nothing for pain and suffering. That is the single most common misunderstanding in a not-at-fault case: people assume that because the crash was clearly the other driver's doing, the other driver's insurer will handle their medical care. It does not work that way in New York, and waiting for the other carrier to start paying is how the thirty-day no-fault deadline gets missed.

Vehicle damage runs on a separate track. You can pursue the at-fault driver's liability carrier for the repairs, which avoids a deductible but depends on that carrier accepting responsibility and moving at its own pace. Or you can go through your own collision coverage, which is faster, and let your insurer pursue reimbursement from the other carrier afterward. A rental or loss of use is handled the same way.

Do You Have to Pay Your Deductible If You Were Not at Fault?

If you repair through your own collision coverage, yes, you pay the deductible up front. Your insurer then pursues the at-fault carrier through subrogation, and when it recovers, you are generally reimbursed for your deductible, in whole or in proportion to the recovery.

If instead you claim directly against the at-fault driver's liability carrier, there is no deductible, because it is not your policy. The trade-off is time and control. That carrier will conduct its own liability investigation before authorizing anything, and if it disputes fault or delays, your car sits.

Two related points. A claim on your own collision coverage after an accident you did not cause should not ordinarily result in a surcharge on your premium, but confirm that with your carrier rather than assuming it. And a repaired vehicle can be worth less than it was before the collision. New York's treatment of that diminished value is limited and depends on the policy and the claim, so ask before you sign a property damage release.

Why Proving Fault Matters More in New York Than It Used To

New York enacted motor vehicle tort reform effective in May 2026 that changed comparative fault in auto cases. A plaintiff whose share of fault exceeds fifty percent in a motor vehicle case now recovers nothing. New York was previously a pure comparative state where a mostly at-fault plaintiff still recovered a reduced amount.

The same legislation eliminated the 90/180 category from the serious injury threshold in Insurance Law Section 5102(d), which previously allowed a person with a medically determined non-permanent injury that disrupted daily activities for ninety of the first one hundred eighty days to recover for pain and suffering. That category is gone. The remaining categories turn on death, dismemberment, significant disfigurement, fracture, loss of a fetus, permanent loss of use, permanent consequential limitation, and significant limitation of use.

The practical consequence for a not-at-fault driver is that the fault allocation is no longer just a discount. It can end the claim. Every scene photograph, every witness name, and every careless word at the roadside now carries more weight than it did before. Because the law is new, its application to a specific accident and filing date should be confirmed rather than assumed.

Should You Talk to the Other Driver's Insurance Company?

You are not obligated to give the other driver's carrier a recorded statement, and you generally should not. Their adjuster works for the company that will pay your claim, and the call usually comes within days, before you know your diagnosis.

You may confirm basic facts: the date, the location, the vehicles involved, and that you are treating. Beyond that, decline politely and say you will follow up in writing or through counsel. The questions that sound conversational are the ones that matter. How fast were you going. Did you see the other car before impact. Were you hurt. Are you feeling better. An honest "I think I'm improving" spoken in week two is quoted back in month ten.

The same caution applies to the early settlement offer. A check arriving before your treatment is complete comes attached to a release that ends the claim permanently, including for injuries that have not fully declared themselves. And never sign a blanket medical authorization, which opens your entire history rather than the records related to this crash.

What If the Other Driver Was Uninsured or Fled?

The claim shifts to your own policy. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage exists precisely for this, and it carries notice conditions that are easy to violate.

Report a hit and run to the police immediately, because prompt reporting is typically a condition of uninsured motorist coverage. Notify your own carrier as soon as practicable, in writing, and identify the claim as an uninsured or underinsured one rather than only a collision claim. Do not settle with the other driver's liability carrier for its policy limits without first getting your own carrier's written consent, because settling without consent can forfeit underinsured coverage entirely. That single misstep costs New Yorkers real money every year.

Underinsured coverage matters even when the other driver has insurance. Minimum limits in New York are low relative to what a serious injury actually costs, and when the at-fault policy is exhausted, your own supplementary coverage may be the only remaining source of recovery.

What Deadlines Apply Even When the Crash Was Not Your Fault?

Fault has nothing to do with the calendar. These run from the date of the accident regardless of who caused it.

  • Thirty days: the no-fault application to the insurer.
  • Forty-five days: submission of medical bills to the no-fault carrier.
  • Ten days: the written accident report to the Department of Motor Vehicles where anyone was injured or property damage exceeds one thousand dollars.
  • Promptly: police reporting of a hit and run, and notice to your own carrier for uninsured or underinsured coverage.
  • Ninety days: a notice of claim under General Municipal Law Section 50-e where the other vehicle was a City vehicle, a transit or MTA bus, or another public vehicle.
  • Three years: the negligence action against a private driver under CPLR 214.
  • Two years: a wrongful death claim under EPTL 5-4.1, measured from the date of death.

What Mistakes Cost People Money in Not-at-Fault Cases?

The recurring ones are all avoidable, and nearly all of them happen in the first two weeks while the injured person is assuming the obvious fault will take care of everything.

  • Waiting to get checked out: the gap between the crash and the first medical visit is the argument the defense makes in every case.
  • Missing the thirty-day no-fault filing: because the other driver was clearly at fault and it seemed like their insurer's problem.
  • Giving a recorded statement: to a carrier whose interests are opposed to yours.
  • Signing a release to close out the vehicle damage: which can extinguish the injury claim along with it. Property damage should be settled on a property damage release alone.
  • Stopping treatment when you feel somewhat better: which reads in the file as recovery rather than as a plateau.
  • Settling with the at-fault carrier without underinsured consent: which can forfeit your own coverage.
  • Assuming a clear police report ends the fault question: carriers dispute liability notwithstanding a report, and under the new fifty percent rule the stakes of that dispute are much higher.

How Do Our New York Car Accident Attorneys Handle These Cases?

We take the administrative burden off the injured person and build the liability proof before it disappears.

  • Free evaluation: the facts, the injuries, the coverage, and an honest assessment of whether you need a lawyer at all.
  • No-fault management: the application filed on time, bills submitted, and denials and benefit terminations challenged.
  • Liability evidence: police records, witness statements, intersection and business camera footage, and vehicle event data before repairs.
  • Coverage investigation: the at-fault driver's limits, any commercial or umbrella policy, and your own uninsured and underinsured coverage, including the consent requirements.
  • Deadline protection: including the ninety-day notice of claim where a public vehicle was involved.
  • Damages documentation: coordinating with treating physicians so imaging, measured limitation, and permanence findings are actually in the record.
  • Suit and discovery: pleadings, bill of particulars, depositions, and defense of the medical examination.
  • Negotiation and trial: resolution on a number that reflects the loss, and trial when the offer does not.

Why Choose Kelner & Kelner for Your New York Car Accident Case?

Kelner & Kelner is a New York City trial firm that has handled catastrophic injury and wrongful death litigation for generations of families, in the Supreme Court in the five boroughs and the surrounding counties, in the federal courts, and on appeal.

Our attorneys have written and lectured on New York trial practice for the state and city bar associations, and appear regularly in the courts where motor vehicle cases are decided. Where a collision causes permanent injury, the case overlaps with our New York catastrophic injury practice. Cases are handled on a contingency fee, which means no legal fee unless there is a recovery. Consultations are free and confidential.

Talk to a New York Car Accident Attorney

Being right about who caused the crash is not the same as being paid for it, and New York's new fifty percent rule means the fault fight can now end a claim outright. If another driver caused your accident, let our New York car accident attorneys review what happened and tell you honestly what we see.

You've Suffered Enough

We'll go after the compensation you deserve. Don't pay a penny unless we win your case. Contact Kelner & Kelner today at (212) 425-0700 or through our website.

Schedule Your Free Consultation


we value your feedback
review us
© 2026 Kelner & Kelner. All rights reserved.

Attorney Advertising | Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.