Call for Free Consultation: 

Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700

Call For Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700

OVER 75 YEARS OF LEGAL EXCELLENCE IN PERSONAL INJURY LAW

Is a Store Liable for a Customer Injury?
March 12, 2025

Is a Store Liable for a Customer Injury?

A store is liable for a customer injury in New York when a dangerous condition on the premises caused the harm and the store created that condition, knew about it, or should have known about it in time to fix it. Liability is not automatic. Being hurt inside a store does not by itself make the store responsible, and the difference usually comes down to notice.

Kelner & Kelner has represented seriously injured New Yorkers for decades, and our New York premises liability attorneys handle store, supermarket, and restaurant injury cases across the five boroughs and the surrounding counties. Robert S. Kelner and the trial lawyers who work with him know these cases are frequently decided by video and paperwork that exist for a matter of weeks. This article expands on our New York personal injury practice.

You've Suffered Enough

We'll go after the compensation you deserve. Don't pay a penny unless we win your case. Contact Kelner & Kelner today at (212) 425-0700 or through our website.

Is a Store Liable for a Customer Injury in New York?

It can be. A business that opens its doors to the public owes every customer a duty of reasonable care to keep the premises in a reasonably safe condition and to warn of hazards it knows about. The store is not an insurer of customer safety, and a fall alone does not establish a claim.

The distinction matters because stores defend these cases on exactly that point. A spill that a customer dropped thirty seconds before you walked through it is a genuine accident. The same spill sitting in an aisle for an hour with cart tracks running through it is a failure of the inspection system the store is supposed to run. Both look identical in the photograph. What separates them is time, and time is proven with records rather than recollection.

This applies to every kind of retail environment: supermarkets, big box stores, pharmacies, delis and bodegas, restaurants, coffee shops, department stores, and shopping centers. It also applies to anyone lawfully on the premises, meaning customers, delivery workers, contractors, and people who came in only to use the restroom.

What Do You Have to Prove Against the Store?

Four elements. That the store owed you a duty of care, that a dangerous condition existed on the premises, that the store created the condition or had actual or constructive notice of it with a reasonable opportunity to correct it, and that the condition caused your injury.

Duty is rarely contested for a customer in a retail space. The dangerous condition is usually visible in a photograph. Causation is usually established by the medical records. Notice is where nearly every store case is won or lost, and there are three separate ways to satisfy it.

  • The store created the condition: an employee mopped without cones, overwatered the produce misters, waxed a floor, stacked merchandise unsafely, or left a pallet jack in an aisle. Where the store made the hazard, no separate proof of notice is required.
  • Actual notice: someone told them. A prior customer complaint, an employee who reported it, a call to the manager, or a maintenance request.
  • Constructive notice: the condition was visible and apparent and existed for a long enough period before the accident that the store should have discovered and remedied it. This is the standard New York courts apply, and it is why the age of the hazard is the central fact.

How Do You Prove the Store Knew About the Hazard?

Through the store's own operational records and its video, neither of which the store hands over voluntarily. Large retailers run documented inspection and sweep programs precisely because they are required to, and those documents either show the aisle was inspected or show it was not.

The record we pursue in a store case typically includes the incident report and any customer statement, the sweep or floor inspection logs for that shift, the store's own safety and inspection policies, employee schedules and assignments for the department, cleaning and maintenance contractor records, prior incident reports and customer complaints at the same location, work orders, refrigeration and freezer service records where condensation or a leak was involved, delivery and stocking schedules, and the surveillance footage.

Video is the priority, and it is perishable. Retail systems commonly overwrite within two to four weeks, and stores frequently preserve only a short clip of the fall itself rather than the thirty or sixty minutes beforehand that would show how long the hazard sat there and how many employees walked past it. A written preservation demand identifying the specific cameras and the specific time range, sent within days, is the single most valuable step in these cases. Where a store destroys footage after being put on notice, New York courts can impose sanctions under CPLR 3126, including an adverse inference instruction telling the jury it may assume the missing video was unfavorable to the store.

What Is the Recurring Condition Rule, and Why Does It Matter in Supermarkets?

Where a store has an ongoing and recurring dangerous condition in a particular area that is routinely left unaddressed, that pattern can itself establish constructive notice of the specific condition that caused the injury. The store cannot escape liability by saying it did not know about this particular puddle when it knew the same puddle formed there every day.

The classic settings are familiar to anyone who shops. The produce misting station that leaves water on the floor on a schedule. The freezer or refrigerated case that has leaked for months and is caught with a mat instead of a repair. The entrance vestibule that floods with tracked-in water every time it rains, where the store puts out mats sometimes and not others. The self-serve beverage or soup station that spills daily.

Proving a recurring condition means proving the pattern rather than the moment. Prior incident reports, repeated work orders for the same equipment, employee testimony that they mop that spot several times a shift, and photographs from other days all establish that the store was managing a known hazard rather than encountering a surprise.

What Kinds of Store Injuries Lead to Claims?

Falls dominate, but they are not the whole picture. Any condition the store controlled and failed to keep reasonably safe can produce a claim, and some of the most serious store injuries have nothing to do with a wet floor.

  • Slip and fall in a store: spills, tracked-in rain and snow, freshly mopped floors without warning, produce debris, leaking coolers, and buffed or waxed surfaces.
  • Trip and fall: curled or unsecured floor mats, extension cords, uneven thresholds, damaged tile, restocking pallets and boxes left in aisles, and low display fixtures.
  • Falling merchandise: improperly stacked or overloaded shelving, items stored above safe height, and warehouse-style racking in big box stores, which produces head and spine injuries.
  • Automatic and manual doors: doors that close too fast, malfunctioning sensors, and glass panels without proper markings.
  • Escalators and elevators: entrapment, sudden stops, missing comb plates, and defective handrails, usually involving the maintenance contractor as well.
  • Shopping carts: defective child seats and restraints, broken wheels, and carts left unsecured in lots on a grade.
  • Parking lots and entrances: potholes, wheel stops, uncleared snow and ice, poor lighting, and unsafe traffic patterns.
  • Stairways and mezzanines: missing handrails, worn treads, and inadequate lighting.
  • Burns and equipment: cafe and food service burns, self-checkout and machinery injuries, and injuries from store equipment operated near customers.
  • Assaults and inadequate security: addressed below.

Who Is Actually Liable: the Store, the Landlord, or a Contractor?

Frequently more than one party, each carrying separate insurance. The name on the storefront is often not the entity that owns the building, and the company that mopped the floor is often not the store at all.

  • The store operator: the tenant in possession, responsible for the interior condition and its own employees. Franchise locations are usually operated by an independent franchisee rather than the national brand.
  • The property owner or landlord: an out-of-possession landlord is generally not liable for conditions inside a leased store, with important exceptions where the lease reserved a right of entry and repair, where the landlord retained control of common areas, or where a structural or statutory violation is involved.
  • Shopping center and mall owners: responsible for common areas, walkways, entrances, and parking lots.
  • Janitorial and cleaning contractors: liable where the contract was comprehensive enough to displace the store's duty or where the contractor created the condition.
  • Snow removal contractors: for lot and walkway conditions in winter.
  • Maintenance and equipment servicers: elevator, escalator, refrigeration, and automatic door contractors.
  • Vendors and stockers: outside distributors who stock their own displays and create hazards while doing so.
  • Product manufacturers: where defective merchandise, shelving, or equipment failed.

Sorting this out early matters because the lease and the service contracts allocate responsibility between these parties, and those documents are obtained in discovery rather than at the customer service desk.

Can a Store Be Liable for an Assault or a Parking Lot Attack?

Yes, in the right circumstances. A business has a duty to take minimal precautions to protect patrons from reasonably foreseeable criminal conduct on its premises. Foreseeability is established through what happened at that location before.

The evidence is the store's own history and the surrounding area's. Prior robberies, assaults, or car break-ins at the location, police calls to the address, the store's own security incident reports, complaints from employees or customers about lighting or loitering, and whether the store contracted for guards or cameras and then failed to provide them. Where a store advertised security it did not deliver, or where cameras were installed as deterrents and left non-functional, those facts matter.

Parking lot and vestibule attacks, altercations with or by store security personnel, and injuries during crowded sale events all fall into this category. So do injuries caused by a store employee's own use of force in a detention, which is a distinct claim.

What Should You Do If You Are Injured in a Store?

Photograph the condition before an employee cleans it, insist on a written incident report, and get the names of witnesses and of the manager. Then get medical attention the same day.

  • Photograph the hazard immediately: wide shots showing the aisle and the location, close shots of the substance or defect, and an object beside it for scale.
  • Photograph what is missing: no cone, no mat, no sign, no barrier.
  • Look up and note the cameras: which ones cover the spot, so they can be identified in a preservation demand.
  • Ask for an incident report and a copy: stores prepare one, and it will exist whether or not you see it. Give the facts, not conclusions about fault or the extent of your injuries.
  • Get names: the manager on duty, the employee who responded, and any customer who saw the fall or the condition.
  • Keep the shoes and clothing: unwashed, since footwear is blamed in nearly every one of these cases.
  • Decline the recorded statement: the store's claims administrator will call within days.
  • Do not accept a gift card or a check that comes with a release: it will resolve the entire claim.

What Will the Store's Insurer Argue?

National retailers use third-party claims administrators who handle these files by formula, and the defenses are consistent enough to anticipate.

The first is no notice, meaning the substance had just been dropped and no employee could have known. The answer is the sweep log, the video, and the physical appearance of the spill. The second is comparative fault, meaning you were looking at your phone, wearing improper shoes, or moving too quickly. Under CPLR 1411, comparative fault reduces a recovery in proportion to your share rather than eliminating it. The third is open and obvious, meaning you should have seen the hazard, which in New York may relieve a store of the duty to warn but does not relieve it of the duty to maintain reasonably safe premises. The fourth is a trivial defect argument in trip cases, where New York applies no fixed measurement and courts examine the width, depth, elevation, irregularity, and appearance of the defect along with the circumstances of the fall. The fifth is a preexisting condition attack on your medical history.

How Long Do You Have to Sue a Store in New York?

Generally three years from the date of the injury under CPLR 214 for a claim against a private store, landlord, or contractor. That is the outside limit, not a reason to wait, because the evidence that decides the case disappears in weeks.

  • CPLR 214: three years for a personal injury claim against a private business or property owner.
  • EPTL 5-4.1: two years from the date of death for a wrongful death claim.
  • CPLR 208: the period is tolled for a child until age eighteen, subject to statutory limits.
  • Public entities: where the store is in a public building, a transit facility, or a public housing development, a notice of claim must generally be served within ninety days under General Municipal Law Section 50-e, with a much shorter period to commence suit.
  • Product claims: where defective merchandise or equipment caused the injury, additional parties and rules may apply.

How Do Our New York Premises Liability Attorneys Handle Store Injury Cases?

We work these files in stages, each one built to put the claim in a posture where a national retailer's claims administrator has to take it seriously.

  • Immediate preservation: a written demand identifying the cameras, the time range, the incident report, and the sweep logs, sent before the system overwrites.
  • Entity investigation: the operating company, the franchisee, the property owner, and every maintenance and cleaning contractor, with the leases and service agreements obtained in discovery.
  • Notice development: inspection logs, prior incidents at the location, repeated work orders, and the store's own written safety policies compared against what actually happened.
  • Deadline protection: a notice of claim where any public entity is involved.
  • Pleadings and particulars: the summons and complaint filed and the bill of particulars specifying the condition, its duration, and every injury claimed.
  • Discovery: depositions of the manager on duty, the employee who responded, the department staff, and the contractor.
  • Spoliation motions: where video or records were destroyed after notice, relief is sought under CPLR 3126.
  • Negotiation and trial: settlement conference or mediation on a number that reflects the actual loss, and trial when the offer does not.

Why Choose Kelner & Kelner for Your Store Injury Case?

Kelner & Kelner is a New York City trial firm that has handled catastrophic injury and wrongful death litigation for generations of families, in the Supreme Court in the five boroughs and the surrounding counties, in the federal courts, and on appeal.

Our attorneys have written and lectured on New York trial practice for the state and city bar associations, and appear regularly in the courts where premises cases against national retailers and property owners are decided. Where a store injury produces a fracture requiring surgery, a head injury, or permanent disability, the case overlaps with our New York catastrophic injury practice. Cases are handled on a contingency fee, which means no legal fee unless there is a recovery. Consultations are free and confidential.

Talk to a New York Premises Liability Attorney

The spill gets mopped, the incident report goes to a claims administrator, and the footage that would prove how long the hazard sat there overwrites within weeks. If a dangerous condition in a store seriously injured you, let our New York premises liability attorneys review what happened and tell you honestly what we see.

You’ve Been Hurt—Now Let Someone Fight for You

You focus on healing. We’ll handle the rest. Call now. Don't pay a penny unless we win your case. Contact Kelner and Kelner today at (212) 425-0700 or through our website.

Schedule Your Free Consultation


we value your feedback
review us
© 2026 Kelner & Kelner. All rights reserved.

Attorney Advertising | Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.