Call for Free Consultation:
Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700
Call For Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700

You likely need a personal injury lawyer if you were seriously hurt, if fault is disputed, if a government entity or a business is involved, if an insurer has asked for a recorded statement or offered a quick settlement, or if a short legal deadline is already running. If your injury resolved in days and nobody is contesting anything, you may not need one at all.
Kelner & Kelner has represented seriously injured New Yorkers and their families for decades, and our New York personal injury attorneys handle cases across the five boroughs and the surrounding counties. Robert S. Kelner and the trial lawyers who work with him tell people honestly when a matter does not warrant a lawyer, because that is part of the job. This article expands on our New York personal injury practice.
We'll go after the compensation you deserve. Don't pay a penny unless we win your case. Contact Kelner & Kelner today at (212) 425-0700 or through our website.
The test is not how upset you are about what happened. It is whether the outcome depends on things you cannot control alone: proving fault, proving the extent of an injury, finding the insurance, and meeting deadlines you may not know exist.
Insurance companies handle these claims for a living. They employ adjusters, in-house counsel, and defense firms, and they evaluate an unrepresented claimant differently from a represented one. That is not a moral point about insurers. It is simply how claims departments are built, and it is the reason the same injury frequently resolves differently depending on who is presenting it.
The countervailing point is equally honest. A contingency fee is a real cost, and a claim that would resolve cleanly for a modest amount does not benefit from counsel. What follows is how to tell which situation you are in.
Any one of these is a reason to at least have the conversation. Several together mean the claim will not resolve fairly on its own.
Earlier than most people think, and the reason is evidence rather than urgency for its own sake. The proof that decides these cases has a shelf life measured in weeks, while the deadline to sue is measured in years.
Surveillance and security footage overwrites, commonly within two to four weeks. Vehicles are repaired or scrapped, taking the physical and electronic evidence with them. Scaffolds come down and job sites are completed. Sidewalk defects get patched, spills get mopped, broken locks get replaced. Witnesses move, change numbers, and forget. None of that waits for you to finish treating.
Some deadlines are genuinely short. A notice of claim against the City, the Housing Authority, a school district, a transit entity, or a public hospital is generally due within ninety days under General Municipal Law Section 50-e. A New York no-fault application is due within thirty days. An injured worker must give written notice to the employer within thirty days. Those clocks run while people are still deciding whether this is serious enough to call someone.
The severity and permanence of the injury drive both whether a claim is worth bringing and how hard it will be to prove.
Certain injuries change the analysis immediately: any fracture, a head injury or diagnosed concussion, a spinal injury or disc herniation with radiating symptoms, significant scarring or disfigurement, an injury requiring surgery, and any injury a physician describes as permanent. In a New York motor vehicle case, this matters legally as well as practically, because recovery for pain and suffering requires meeting the statutory serious injury threshold in Insurance Law Section 5102(d), a threshold that was narrowed by legislation effective in May 2026.
Delayed and cumulative injuries deserve attention too. Symptoms that appear days later, that worsen instead of improving, or that persist past the point a provider expected recovery all indicate something structural. So does an injury that has ended or threatens a career, particularly in the trades, where the loss of physical capacity is the loss of the work itself.
Some defendants change the case entirely. When any of these is involved, the claim is no longer a simple insurance transaction.
Adjuster conduct is one of the most reliable indicators, because insurers move fastest on the claims they consider most valuable and most vulnerable.
The early call asking for a recorded statement, before you have a diagnosis, is one. So is the quick offer, arriving with a release that ends everything including injuries that have not fully appeared. So is a broad medical authorization that opens your entire history rather than the records related to this incident. So is a denial of liability that contradicts the police report or the physical evidence, and a request that you provide a statement in support of the other side's version.
Watch for the quieter signals too. Benefits terminated after an examination arranged by the carrier. Bills being denied on technical grounds. A file transferred to a new adjuster repeatedly. Delay that pushes you toward accepting less because bills are accumulating. Each of these is a normal part of claims handling, and each of them is more effective against someone handling it alone.
They exist, and a firm worth hiring will say so. If the injury was minor and fully resolved, no treatment beyond an initial visit was needed, no work was missed, fault is undisputed, and the insurer has accepted responsibility and made a reasonable offer, a contingency fee may take more than counsel adds.
Property damage alone is the clearest example. Repair estimates, vehicle valuations, and a rental are a transaction you can manage, and there is no injury claim to preserve. Small claims court exists for modest disputes and is designed to be used without a lawyer.
Two cautions even here. Do not sign a general release to resolve property damage, because it can extinguish an injury claim you do not yet know you have. And a free consultation costs nothing, so the choice is never between hiring a lawyer and finding out where you stand.
The visible part is negotiation. The part that determines the outcome happens earlier and is mostly invisible to the client.
Personal injury cases are handled on a contingency fee. The fee is a percentage of the recovery, and there is no legal fee unless there is a recovery. Consultations are free and confidential, and there is no obligation to hire anyone after one.
Case expenses are separate from the fee and cover things like record retrieval, filing fees, deposition transcripts, and the professionals who analyze evidence. A firm that takes serious cases advances those costs. Ask any firm you speak with how expenses are handled and how they are treated at resolution, and ask who will actually work on the file.
The comparison worth making is not fee against no fee. It is the represented outcome, after fees and after lien negotiation, against the unrepresented one, taking into account the claims and coverage you may not have identified on your own.
You describe what happened, someone asks focused questions, and you get an assessment. Nothing is signed unless you decide to move forward, and the conversation is confidential whether you hire the firm or not.
Bring what you have: the police or incident report, photographs, the names of any witnesses, insurance information, discharge paperwork and medical records, correspondence from any insurer, and anything you were asked to sign. Ask directly whether the firm believes you have a viable claim, what deadlines apply to your specific situation, what the case would require, and what the realistic range of outcomes looks like.
You should expect a straight answer, including a negative one. A firm that tells everyone who calls that they have a strong case is not evaluating anything.
We start with the two questions that determine everything: can liability be proven, and what did the injury actually cost this person.
Kelner & Kelner is a New York City trial firm that has handled catastrophic injury and wrongful death litigation for generations of families, in the Supreme Court in the five boroughs and the surrounding counties, in the federal courts, and on appeal.
Our attorneys have written and lectured on New York trial practice for the state and city bar associations, and appear regularly in the courts where these cases are decided. The firm concentrates on serious cases: catastrophic injuries, complex medical records, and high exposure claims where a carrier's willingness to pay depends on whether it believes a jury will hear the case. Cases are handled on a contingency fee, which means no legal fee unless there is a recovery.
You do not have to decide whether you need a lawyer before you talk to one. Tell us what happened, and our New York personal injury attorneys will tell you honestly what we see, including if the answer is that you can handle it yourself.
We'll go after the compensation you deserve. Don't pay a penny unless we win your case. Contact Kelner & Kelner today at (212) 425-0700 or through our website.

Attorney Advertising | Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.