Call for Free Consultation: 

Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700

Call For Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700

OVER 75 YEARS OF LEGAL EXCELLENCE IN PERSONAL INJURY LAW

January 8, 2025

Common Causes of Railroad Injuries

Most railroad injuries trace back to a small number of recurring failures: unsafe grade crossings, platform and gap hazards, defective track and equipment, operator error and fatigue, inadequate warning systems, and unsafe working conditions for rail employees. Each cause points to a different responsible party and a different set of records, which is why identifying the cause early shapes everything that follows.

Kelner & Kelner has represented seriously injured New Yorkers and the families of people killed on the region's rail systems for decades, and our New York railroad injury attorneys handle cases arising on the subway, the Long Island Rail Road, Metro-North, Amtrak, and freight lines across the five boroughs and the surrounding counties. Robert S. Kelner and the trial lawyers who work with him build these files from the first preservation letter forward as if a jury will decide them. This article expands on our New York mass transit accident practice.

What Are the Most Common Causes of Railroad Injuries?

Railroad injuries are rarely random. They cluster around conditions the railroad controls and is required to inspect, and around the points where trains and people come closest together. The causes below account for the large majority of the serious cases our firm reviews.

  • Grade crossing failures: gates that do not lower, lights that do not activate, obstructed sightlines, and crossings with no active warning devices at all.
  • Platform and gap hazards: excessive gaps between car and platform, wet or icy platforms, defective platform edges, missing tactile warning strips, and inadequate lighting.
  • Door and passenger handling failures: doors closing on passengers, trains moving with doors obstructed, and trains starting before boarding is complete.
  • Defective or poorly maintained track: broken rails, misaligned joints, sun kinks, failed ties, and washouts, all of which are governed by federal track safety standards requiring regular inspection.
  • Equipment and mechanical failure: brake defects, wheel and axle failures, coupler failures, and defective locomotive components.
  • Operator error and fatigue: excessive speed through curves and restricted zones, signals passed at danger, distraction, and crews working under punishing hours of service.
  • Signal and dispatch failures: conflicting movements, improper track authority, and gaps in train control systems.
  • Station and stairway conditions: broken steps, missing handrails, defective escalators and elevators, water intrusion, and poor lighting.
  • Inadequate security: assaults on platforms and in passageways where the operator knew of a pattern of prior criminal activity and failed to take reasonable precautions.
  • Track and right of way access: unfenced or inadequately secured right of way, particularly where a railroad knew of a longstanding informal crossing used by the public.
  • Third rail and electrification contact: contact with energized rail after a fall from a platform or during evacuation of a stalled train.
  • Unsafe working conditions for rail employees: covered separately below, because railroad workers have their own federal remedy.

What Causes Injuries at Railroad Crossings?

Crossing injuries are usually the product of a warning system that failed, a sightline that was blocked, or a crossing that was never adequately protected in the first place. These collisions are catastrophic almost by definition, because a train cannot stop and the vehicle absorbs the entire force.

The recurring failures are mechanical and organizational. Gates and flashing lights are governed by federal grade crossing signal system standards that require periodic testing and maintenance, and the maintenance records show whether the devices were tested, whether they had failed before, and whether the railroad knew. Vegetation, parked equipment, stored railcars, and structures near the right of way can block a driver's view of an approaching train, and the railroad is responsible for maintaining sightlines it controls. Crossings marked only with a crossbuck sign, with no gates or lights, place the entire burden on the motorist to detect a train that may be traveling far faster than it appears.

Passive causes matter as much as active ones. Rough or elevated crossing surfaces that stall low clearance vehicles, signal timing that gives inadequate warning, and crossings where a nearby traffic light backs vehicles onto the tracks are conditions the railroad and the roadway authority are supposed to evaluate together.

What Causes Platform, Station, and Boarding Injuries?

On a commuter or subway system, most passenger injuries happen before or after the ride rather than during it. Platform edges, gaps, stairs, escalators, and doors are where transit operators generate the most claims, and where their own inspection records usually tell the story.

The gap between the car and the platform on curved platforms is a chronic hazard, and where the operator knows a particular station has an oversized gap, the adequacy of its warnings, lighting, and gap fillers becomes the question. Doors that close on a passenger or on a bag, and trains that begin moving with a passenger caught, involve both mechanical door sensitivity and crew observation practices. Escalator and elevator failures in stations involve the transit agency and its maintenance contractor. Slippery platforms in winter, water intrusion from chronic leaks, and burned out lighting in passageways all turn on the same actual and constructive notice questions that govern any premises case.

What Causes Train Derailments?

Derailments generally come from four sources: track defects, equipment failures, excessive speed, and human factors in dispatching or operation. Federal investigators reconstruct these events from the same materials that drive a civil case, which is one reason derailment claims should be pursued alongside, not after, the official investigation.

Track causes include broken rails, buckled track in heat, failed ties and fasteners, and inadequate ballast, all subject to federally mandated inspection intervals whose records are discoverable. Equipment causes include wheel, axle, bearing, and brake failures, along with defective or improperly loaded freight cars. Speed remains a recurring factor, particularly at curves and transitions where the permissible speed drops sharply and the consequences of an overspeed entry are severe. Human factors include fatigue, medical impairment, distraction, and inadequate training, and they are evaluated against the railroad's own operating rules.

How Do Railroad Workers Get Hurt, and What Is FELA?

Railroad employees are not covered by state workers compensation. They bring claims under the Federal Employers' Liability Act, 45 U.S.C. Sections 51 through 60, which allows an injured railroad worker to sue the employer for negligence. It is a fault based system, but the worker's burden is lighter than in an ordinary negligence case.

Under FELA, a railroad is liable if its negligence played any part, however slight, in producing the injury. Contributory negligence reduces the recovery proportionally rather than barring it, and where the railroad violated a federal safety statute, such as the Safety Appliance Act or the Locomotive Inspection Act, the worker's own negligence is not counted at all. The limitations period is three years from the date the claim accrued under 45 U.S.C. Section 56, and occupational injuries that develop over time accrue when the worker knew or should have known of the injury and its work connection.

The injuries follow the work: falls from equipment and ballast walking surfaces, crush and coupling injuries, repetitive trauma from vibration and awkward positions, hearing loss from prolonged noise exposure, and exposure to diesel exhaust, solvents, and silica. Railroad workers should know that a report filed with the employer's claims department is not a substitute for advice from a lawyer who does not work for the railroad.

Who Can Be Held Responsible for a Railroad Injury in New York?

Often more than one party, and the right defendant depends on which system was involved. The subway, the commuter railroads, Amtrak, and freight carriers are different entities with different rules, different insurance, and very different deadlines.

  • New York City Transit Authority: the subway and city bus system, a public benefit corporation subject to notice of claim requirements.
  • The Metropolitan Transportation Authority and its subsidiaries: including the Long Island Rail Road and Metro-North Railroad, each of which must be identified and served correctly.
  • Amtrak: the National Railroad Passenger Corporation, which operates under federal law but is sued as a corporation.
  • Freight railroads: private corporations responsible for their own track, equipment, crews, and crossing maintenance.
  • Maintenance and construction contractors: signal contractors, track contractors, elevator and escalator servicers, and station construction firms.
  • Equipment manufacturers: where a defective component caused or contributed to the event.
  • Municipalities and roadway authorities: where roadway design, signal timing, or sightline maintenance at a crossing contributed.
  • Motor vehicle drivers and their carriers: in crossing collisions where a vehicle was on the tracks.

Federal law adds a layer that ordinary injury cases do not have. The Federal Railroad Safety Act, at 49 U.S.C. Section 20106, can preempt state law claims where a federal regulation substantially subsumes the subject matter, while expressly preserving claims that a railroad failed to comply with a federal standard or with its own safety plan. Framing the claim correctly at the pleading stage matters.

How Long Do You Have to Bring a Railroad Injury Claim in New York?

It depends entirely on who operated the train. Against a private railroad, the period is measured in years. Against a public transit entity, the first deadline arrives in ninety days, and missing it generally ends the claim no matter how clear the liability.

  • Public transit entities: a notice of claim must generally be served within ninety days under General Municipal Law Section 50-e, applied through Public Authorities Law Section 1212 for the New York City Transit Authority and Section 1276 for the Metropolitan Transportation Authority and its subsidiaries. The period to commence suit is shorter than the ordinary negligence period and is measured differently by entity, so it should be confirmed for your specific defendant rather than assumed.
  • General Municipal Law 50-h: the entity may demand a hearing at which you are examined under oath before suit is filed.
  • Private railroads, including Amtrak and freight carriers: the personal injury claim is generally governed by the three-year period in CPLR 214.
  • FELA claims by railroad employees: three years from accrual under 45 U.S.C. Section 56.
  • Wrongful death: under EPTL 5-4.1, the claim is generally brought within two years of the date of death, and a notice of claim requirement still applies where the defendant is a public entity.
  • CPLR 208: the limitations period is tolled for a child until age eighteen, subject to statutory limits, and the toll does not excuse an untimely notice of claim on its own.

What Evidence Proves a Railroad Injury Case?

Railroads generate an unusual volume of technical data, and nearly all of it overwrites, cycles, or gets archived on a schedule. The single most valuable step in the first week is a written demand that the operator preserve it.

The record we pursue typically includes the locomotive event recorder data showing speed, throttle, and brake application, forward facing and inward facing camera footage, station and platform surveillance video, dispatch and radio recordings, signal and crossing device maintenance and test records, track inspection reports, equipment maintenance and defect reports, crew hours of service records, post incident testing, the operator's own internal incident report and any root cause analysis, prior complaints and prior incidents at the same location, and the applicable operating rules and bulletins in effect that day.

Where the National Transportation Safety Board or the Federal Railroad Administration investigates, the factual materials that emerge are valuable, although federal law limits how agency conclusions may be used at trial. Our New York railroad injury attorneys develop the civil case on its own record rather than waiting for an agency to finish.

What Injuries and Losses Do These Cases Involve?

Rail forces are enormous, and the injuries reflect that. Traumatic brain injury, spinal cord injury, amputation, crush injuries, severe burns from electrification and fire, and death are common outcomes rather than exceptional ones.

New York does not cap damages in these cases. A recovery can include past and future medical care, surgery and rehabilitation, prosthetics and assistive equipment, home modification and attendant care, past and future lost earnings and lost earning capacity, and compensation for pain, suffering, disability, disfigurement, and loss of enjoyment of life. Where the injuries are catastrophic, the case overlaps with our New York catastrophic injury practice, and a life care plan becomes central to what the case is worth. Where a passenger, motorist, or worker was killed, the claim proceeds as a wrongful death action together with a survival claim for conscious pain and suffering.

How Do Our New York Railroad Injury Attorneys Handle These Cases?

We work these files in stages, each one built to put the claim in a posture where a railroad and its carrier have to take it seriously.

  • Immediate preservation: written demands for event recorder data, camera footage, dispatch audio, and maintenance records before retention periods run.
  • Scene and equipment inspection: the crossing, platform, or track segment documented and measured before conditions are altered.
  • Deadline protection: where a public transit entity is involved, the notice of claim is served on the correct entity within the statutory window and the 50-h hearing is prepared for.
  • Defendant identification: the operator, the contractors, the manufacturers, and any roadway authority with a role in the condition.
  • Pleadings and particulars: the summons and complaint are filed and the bill of particulars specifies every failure and every injury claimed.
  • Discovery: document production and depositions of the crew, the dispatchers, the signal and track personnel, and the supervisors who set the practices.
  • Damages development: treating physicians, rehabilitation providers, vocational analysis, and a life care plan where the injury is permanent.
  • Motion practice and negotiation: opposition to summary judgment and to preemption arguments, then settlement conference or mediation on a number that reflects the actual loss.
  • Trial: when the offer does not reflect the harm, the case is tried.

Why Choose Kelner & Kelner for Your Railroad Injury Case?

Kelner & Kelner is a New York City trial firm that has handled catastrophic injury and wrongful death litigation for generations of families, in the Supreme Court in the five boroughs and the surrounding counties, in the federal courts, and on appeal.

Our attorneys have written and lectured on New York trial practice for the state and city bar associations, and appear regularly in the courts where claims against transit authorities and railroads are decided. Cases are handled on a contingency fee, which means no legal fee unless there is a recovery. Consultations are free and confidential.

Talk to a New York Railroad Injury Attorney

Event recorder data cycles, camera footage overwrites, and a transit claim can expire in ninety days while a family is still in the hospital. If a railroad or transit system seriously injured you or took someone you love, let our New York railroad injury attorneys review what happened and tell you honestly what we see.

You've Suffered Enough

We'll go after the compensation you deserve. Don't pay a penny unless we win your case. Contact Kelner & Kelner today at (212) 425-0700 or through our website.

Schedule Your Free Consultation


we value your feedback
review us
© 2026 Kelner & Kelner. All rights reserved.

Attorney Advertising | Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.