Call for Free Consultation: 

Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700

Call For Free Consultation: (212) 425-0700

OVER 75 YEARS OF LEGAL EXCELLENCE IN PERSONAL INJURY LAW

Can I Sue an Apartment Complex for Negligence?
February 3, 2025

Can I Sue an Apartment Complex for Negligence?

Yes. You can sue an apartment complex for negligence in New York when a dangerous condition on the property caused your injury and the owner knew about it, or should have known about it, and failed to fix it in a reasonable time. The claim runs against whoever owned, controlled, or maintained the area where you were hurt, and there is often more than one responsible party.

Kelner & Kelner has represented seriously injured New Yorkers and their families for decades, and our New York premises liability attorneys handle building injury cases across the five boroughs and the surrounding counties. Robert S. Kelner and the trial lawyers who work with him build these files as if a jury will decide them, because that is frequently what it takes to move a building's insurance carrier off a low number. This article expands on our New York personal injury practice.

You've Suffered Enough

We'll go after the compensation you deserve. Don't pay a penny unless we win your case. Contact Kelner & Kelner today at (212) 425-0700 or through our website.

Can You Sue an Apartment Complex for Negligence in New York?

You can, and the claim is a personal injury case rather than a housing dispute. New York property owners owe everyone lawfully on the premises a duty of reasonable care under the circumstances. When a broken step, an unlit stairwell, a defective elevator, or an unsecured entrance door causes serious harm, the owner answers for it in Supreme Court.

That is different from a landlord tenant matter about rent, repairs, or the condition of your unit, which belongs in Housing Court and follows an entirely different body of law. Our firm handles the injury side: the fall, the assault, the elevator drop, the fire, the falling ceiling. If you were hurt on the property, the question is not whether you are a tenant in good standing. It is whether the building was reasonably safe and whether the owner had a fair opportunity to make it so.

Guests, delivery workers, contractors, home health aides, and visitors have the same right to bring a claim that a tenant does. So does someone injured in a common area of a building where they do not live. The duty attaches to the property and to the people who control it, not to the lease.

What Do You Have to Prove Against the Building Owner?

Four things: that the owner owed you a duty of care, that a dangerous condition existed, that the owner created the condition or had actual or constructive notice of it and a reasonable chance to correct it, and that the condition caused your injury. Notice is where most apartment cases are won or lost.

Actual notice means someone told them. A complaint to the superintendent, a work order, a 311 call, a violation issued by the Department of Buildings or the Department of Housing Preservation and Development, an email to management, or a prior accident in the same spot all establish that the owner knew. Constructive notice means the condition was visible and apparent and existed long enough before the accident that the owner should have discovered and remedied it. A tread that has worn through, a handrail missing for months, a light fixture that residents had complained about repeatedly, and a puddle from a chronic roof leak are all constructive notice conditions.

The exception is where the owner created the condition. When building staff waxed a lobby floor and left it slick, or a porter piled debris on a landing, notice does not have to be proven separately. The party that made the hazard is charged with knowing about it.

What Kinds of Apartment Building Injuries Support a Claim?

Any condition the owner controlled and failed to keep reasonably safe can support a negligence claim. The cases that produce serious injuries concentrate in stairs, elevators, entrances, and exterior walkways.

  • Stairway falls: broken or uneven treads, missing or loose handrails, worn nosing, and stairwells with burned out lighting.
  • Elevator injuries: misleveling, doors that close on passengers, sudden drops, and entrapments, often involving both the building and the elevator maintenance company.
  • Slip and fall in an apartment building: wet lobby floors without warning, tracked in water at entrances, leaking pipes, and mopping without cones.
  • Snow and ice: untreated walkways, courtyards, ramps, and parking areas.
  • Falling ceilings and collapsing fixtures: plaster failures from long standing leaks, cabinets and light fixtures pulling out of walls.
  • Fires and burns: blocked or chained exits, missing or inoperative smoke alarms, and defective wiring.
  • Lobby and hallway defects: raised or broken tiles, torn carpet, uncovered floor openings, and defective thresholds.
  • Playground, courtyard, laundry room, and parking garage conditions: broken equipment, potholes, inadequate lighting, and unsecured machinery.
  • Dog attacks in common areas: where the owner knew of an animal's vicious propensity and had the ability to control its presence in the building.
  • Assaults connected to poor security: covered in its own section below.

Where these conditions produce catastrophic harm, including brain injury, spinal cord injury, amputation, or severe burns, the case overlaps with our New York catastrophic injury practice, and lifetime care needs become central to what the case is worth.

Who Is Actually Responsible: the Owner, the Management Company, or Someone Else?

Frequently several parties at once, each carrying separate insurance. Identifying all of them early is one of the most valuable things a lawyer does in an apartment case, because the entity named on the lease is often not the entity that owns the building or maintained the thing that hurt you.

  • The record owner: usually a limited liability company holding a single building, identified through the city's property records.
  • The managing agent: a separate company that hires staff, handles complaints, and schedules repairs, and that can be liable where it displaced the owner's duty to maintain.
  • A net lessee: an entity leasing the entire building and operating it, which frequently assumes the maintenance obligations.
  • The elevator maintenance contractor: under a service contract, with its own inspection records and its own carrier.
  • Snow removal and landscaping contractors: liable where the contract was comprehensive enough to displace the owner's duty, or where the contractor made the condition worse.
  • Security companies: where guards, cameras, or door staff were contracted for and not provided.
  • Co-op and condominium boards: responsible for common elements even where individual units are separately owned.
  • The New York City Housing Authority: a public authority with a much shorter deadline, described below.

What If You Were Attacked in Your Building?

A New York building owner has a common law duty to take minimal precautions to protect tenants and visitors from reasonably foreseeable criminal conduct. Where an assault happened because a door lock was broken, an intercom did not work, or a lobby went unattended, the owner can be liable for the attack.

The Court of Appeals set the framework in Nallan v. Helmsley-Spear and refined it in Burgos v. Aqueduct Realty. Foreseeability is usually established through the building's own history: prior crimes in the building or on the block, police reports, tenant complaints about the front door, and management's own knowledge that the lock had been broken for weeks. A plaintiff does not have to identify the attacker by name. What must be shown is enough evidence for a reasonable inference that the assailant was an intruder who got in through a negligently maintained entrance.

Building security evidence disappears quickly. Camera footage overwrites, door hardware gets replaced, and repair tickets get closed out. A written preservation demand in the first days after an assault is frequently what keeps the case alive.

How Do You Prove the Landlord Knew About the Dangerous Condition?

Through the building's own paper trail. Owners rarely admit knowledge, and they do not have to, because the records they are required to keep and the complaints residents already filed usually establish it for them.

The record we assemble in an apartment case typically includes Department of Buildings and Housing Preservation and Development violation histories, 311 complaint records for the address, the building's work order and repair logs, maintenance and inspection records, elevator service tickets and inspection certificates, prior accident and incident reports, the superintendent's logbook, tenant complaint correspondence, security camera footage, staffing and porter schedules, and photographs taken before repairs are made.

From there the case proceeds through New York's discovery process: a bill of particulars specifying each defect and each failure alleged, document demands, and depositions of the superintendent, the porters, the managing agent, and the contractors. Buildings frequently repair a defect immediately after an accident, which is why photographs taken in the first days matter enormously and why counsel should be involved before the evidence changes.

What About a Fall on the Sidewalk Outside the Building?

In New York City, Administrative Code Section 7-210 shifts responsibility for maintaining the sidewalk to the abutting property owner. An apartment building owner is liable for a defective or icy sidewalk in front of the property. The main exception is an owner-occupied one, two, or three family home used exclusively as a residence, where liability generally remains with the City.

Snow and ice carry their own timing rules. Administrative Code Section 16-123 requires removal within four hours after the snow stops falling, with the hours between 9:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. excluded from that count. New York also recognizes a storm in progress defense, meaning an owner is generally not liable for failing to clear accumulation while precipitation is still falling. Establishing when the storm ended, using certified weather data rather than memory, is routine work in these cases.

How Long Do You Have to Sue an Apartment Complex in New York?

For a private building owner, the negligence claim is generally governed by the three-year period in CPLR 214. Against public housing, the deadline is far shorter, and missing it ends the claim regardless of how strong the case is.

  • CPLR 214: three years from the date of the accident for a personal injury claim against a private owner, managing agent, or contractor.
  • EPTL 5-4.1: where the injury caused death, the wrongful death claim is generally brought within two years of the date of death.
  • CPLR 208: the limitations period is tolled for a child until age eighteen, subject to statutory limits.
  • New York City Housing Authority and other public landlords: a notice of claim must generally be served within ninety days under General Municipal Law Section 50-e, and suit commenced within one year and ninety days under Section 50-i. A hearing under Section 50-h may be demanded before suit.
  • Claims against the City itself: where the City is the responsible party, the same ninety-day notice requirement applies, and for many roadway and sidewalk defects the City must also have received prior written notice of the condition.
  • CPLR 214-c: for injuries from exposure to a harmful substance, the period runs from discovery of the injury.

The ninety-day rule is the one that quietly ends cases. A resident of a public development who assumes there are three years to decide what to do may lose the claim in the first season after the accident.

Does Your Lease Change Anything?

Not on the negligence question. Under General Obligations Law Section 5-321, a lease provision purporting to exempt a landlord from liability for its own negligence in the operation or maintenance of the property is void and unenforceable. A clause telling you the owner is not responsible for injuries does not defeat your claim.

Two related points come up constantly. Being behind on rent, or being in a dispute with management, has no bearing on your right to recover for an injury. And New York follows comparative fault under CPLR 1411, so being partly responsible for your own accident reduces a recovery in proportion to your share of fault rather than eliminating it. Carriers frequently argue that a resident who used a stairway they knew was defective is entirely to blame. That is an argument about percentages, not about whether a claim exists.

What Is an Apartment Building Injury Case Worth?

New York does not cap damages in these cases. A recovery can include past and future medical expenses, surgery and rehabilitation, home care and future care needs, past and future lost earnings and lost earning capacity, out of pocket costs, and compensation for pain, suffering, disability, disfigurement, and loss of enjoyment of life.

Value tracks the permanence of the injury and the quality of the proof on notice. A fractured ankle that heals is a different case from a spinal fusion that ends a career, and a defect the building had been cited for twice is a different case from one nobody had ever complained about. A spouse may bring a derivative claim for loss of services and companionship. Where the injury caused a death, damages in New York remain limited to pecuniary loss for the wrongful death claim, with conscious pain and suffering recoverable through the survival claim.

How Do Our New York Premises Liability Attorneys Handle These Cases?

We work these files in stages, each one designed to put the claim in a posture where the building's carrier has to take it seriously.

  • Preservation: written demands to preserve camera footage, work orders, door hardware, and the defective condition itself before it is repaired away.
  • Ownership investigation: property records, managing agent identification, contractor agreements, and the insurance behind each entity.
  • Notice development: violation histories, 311 records, complaint correspondence, and prior accidents at the same location.
  • Deadline protection: where a public landlord is involved, the notice of claim is served within the statutory window and the 50-h hearing is prepared for.
  • Pleadings and particulars: the summons and complaint are filed and the bill of particulars specifies every defect and every injury claimed.
  • Discovery: document production and depositions of the superintendent, the porters, the managing agent, and every contractor with a role in the condition.
  • Motion practice and negotiation: opposition to summary judgment on notice, then settlement conference or mediation on a number that reflects what the client actually lost.
  • Trial: when the offer does not reflect the harm, the case is tried, and preparing from the first day forward is what makes that a real option.

Why Choose Kelner & Kelner for Your Apartment Injury Case?

Kelner & Kelner is a New York City trial firm that has handled catastrophic injury and wrongful death litigation for generations of families, in the Supreme Court in the five boroughs and the surrounding counties, in the federal courts, and on appeal.

Our attorneys have written and lectured on New York trial practice for the state and city bar associations, and appear regularly in the courts where premises cases against building owners and public landlords are decided. Cases are handled on a contingency fee, which means no legal fee unless there is a recovery. Consultations are free and confidential.

Talk to a New York Premises Liability Attorney

Buildings repair the defect, overwrite the footage, and close the work order long before a carrier makes an offer. If a dangerous condition in an apartment building seriously injured you, let our New York premises liability attorneys review what happened and tell you honestly what we see.

You've Suffered Enough

We'll go after the compensation you deserve. Don't pay a penny unless we win your case. Contact Kelner & Kelner today at (212) 425-0700 or through our website.

Schedule Your Free Consultation


we value your feedback
review us
© 2026 Kelner & Kelner. All rights reserved.

Attorney Advertising | Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.